Pendle vs Kamino: which yield protocol comes out ahead
Kamino Finance demonstrated stability by processing 55,649 liquidations without bad debt during a SOL crash, while Pendle faced a $27 million loss via the PenPie exploit. Kamino proves more resilient to volatility compared to Pendle's permissionless market risks.
Kamino handles the volatility
Kamino Finance handled a massive liquidation event on February 5-6, 2026, when SOL fell 18% from $92 to $76. The sell-off unfolded over 48 hours, with ETH falling from $2,148 to $1,832 and JLP declining 10.4% to $3.43. The protocol seized $19.36M in collateral from 30,030 wallets during this period. On February 5, volatility triggered 29,185 liquidations and seized $8.77M as SOL broke below $85. On February 6, the crash to $76 caused 26,464 liquidations and $10.59M in seizures. Uncorrelated positions accounted for 99.6% of the volume, totaling $19.29M, while correlated pairs saw only $68K in activity. The JLP/USDC and SOL/USDC pairs alone accounted for $9.86M, which was 51% of the total collateral seized during the 48-hour period when SOL prices fell from $92 to $76. The JLP market specifically saw $6.47M in collateral seized. While the Main market supply fell 8.3% to $1,543M, the Prime market grew by $55M in supply and $42M in borrow. The Main market supply reached a trough of $1,385M before recovering to $1,543M. The collateral seized included $6.89M in SOL, $6.58M in JLP, $2.14M in JITOSOL, and $1.67M in cbBTC. I find Kamino’s ability to process 55,649 liquidations without generating any bad debt highly impressive. Total supply reached $2.70B and total borrow reached $1.00B. Regarding risk, 81.2% of positions stay in the Safe tier with a distance to liquidation above 25%.
Pendle and the PenPie exploit
Pendle splits yield-bearing assets into Principal Tokens (PT) and Yield Tokens (YT) to allow for fixed income and yield speculation. The SY token standard wraps assets like stETH or sUSDe to facilitate this process. Users buy PT at a discount to receive the underlying asset at maturity or buy YT to gain exposure to future yields. You already know the basics of yield splitting, so focus on how these protocols survive volatility. In the Pendle ecosystem, the PenPie protocol suffered a $27 million loss on September 3, 2024. The attacker injected a malicious SY contract using the PendleYieldContractFactory and then created a fake market via the PendleMarketFactoryV3 to facilitate the theft of 11,113.6 ETH across both the Ethereum and Arbitrum networks. This exploit targeted the assumption that all markets created by the Pendle Factory contract are legitimate. The attacker used flash loans for agETH and rswETH from Balancer to amplify the theft. The attacker used the batchHarvestMarketRewards function to trigger the redeemRewards function of the fake Pendle market, allowing the malicious SY contract to claim rewards. I find the PenPie exploit a massive failure in the security of Pendle’s permissionless market registration.
Choosing between stability and innovation
| Protocol | Metric | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Kamino | Total Supply | $2.70B |
| Kamino | Total Borrow | $1.00B |
| Kamino | Collateral Seized (Feb 2026) | $19.36M |
| Pendle | Total Value Locked | $6.5B |
| PenPie | Loss (Sept 2024) | $27M |
Kamino handles massive price swings like the February 2026 SOL crash without leaving the protocol with bad debt. In contrast, Pendle’s reliance on external integrations like PenPie creates a surface for exploits. The PenPie attack exploited the PendleStakingBaseUpg contract to allow continuous, illegitimate deposits. This event drained funds from multiple PenPie pools using the batchHarvestMarketRewards function. I select Kamino as the superior choice for stability because its liquidation engines handled 55,649 events cleanly while Pendle’s ecosystem suffered a $27 million drain. Can Pendle improve its verification of third-party SY contracts to prevent similar PenPie losses?
Join the discussion