Live
USD · 24h
DeFi

VanEck withdraws stETH ETF filing as concentration risks persist

VanEck has withdrawn its registration for a proposed Lido Staked ETH ETF following concerns over validator concentration. Lido currently holds roughly $40 billion in value locked, representing up to 33% of all staked ETH, which raises operational risks for the Ethereum network.

VanEck withdraws stETH ETF filing as concentration risks persist

The economics of the proposed VanEck stETH ETF

VanEck filed a request on October 14, 2026, to withdraw its registration for a proposed Lido Staked ETH ETF through a Form RW filing. This request follows an initial S-1 registration statement from October 16, 2025, targeting the MarketVector Lido Staked Ethereum Benchmark Rate index. The fund intended to hold stETH, which pays a 3-5% APY after Lido takes a 10% fee, and would have used 10,000 shares per 1,000 stETH for redemption baskets to maintain liquidity. Because the product captures staking rewards, it attracts interest from institutions seeking DeFi yields through traditional wrappers that bypass technical barriers like running validators. The stETH price stabilized near a 0.99-1.01 ETH peg after a 5% dip following the October 2025 prospectus news. LDO, the governance token for Lido, surged 3-17% in the week following the initial Delaware filing. You already know that staking rewards drive interest, so consider how the fund planned to manage liquidity.

Protocol TVL Avg APY
Lido Liquid Staking $17.6B 2.24%
Binance Staked ETH $7.0B 2.20%
ether.fi Stake $3.4B 1.95%
Rocket Pool $867.4M 1.84%

Regulatory shifts and validator concentration

The SEC ruled that tokens under liquid staking arrangements do not qualify as securities when they lack centralized profit promises. This decision allows Lido to expand its services to banks and asset managers. Lido holds roughly $40 billion in value locked, which accounts for 23-33% of all staked ETH. This dominance attracts scrutiny from Ethereum developers who discuss caps on liquid staking dominance. Ganesh Swami, CEO of Covalent, states that if multiple ETFs use identical custodians, this concentration increases operational risks like malicious collusion. The success of spot ETH ETFs, which drew $15 billion in inflows in their first six months, supports the demand for these products. BlackRock also filed a Nasdaq proposal to allow staking in its Ethereum ETF, which triggers a 21-day public consultation period. The SEC has up to 90 days to approve or disapprove the application. Analysts at Bernstein estimate a 75% surge for ETH following an ETF approval, similar to the rally seen after the January Bitcoin ETF launches. Coinbase serves as the custodian for 90% of the total assets in the U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs, which have a market capitalization of $54 billion. Do regulators have the power to prevent a single entity from controlling a large portion of the consensus mechanism?

Security incidents and the unstaking queue

The Ethereum unstaking queue reached 910,461 ETH, worth roughly $3.91 billion, which marks the highest exit request total since the Shapella upgrade. This backlog grew as validators sought to rebalance portfolios or react to market volatility. MetaMask withdrew its Ethereum validators from Lido as a precaution following an infrastructure security incident. These 17,000 validators held approximately 523,000 ETH. The withdrawal process takes up to 45 days because the network’s entry and exit queues limit the number of validators that can exit per epoch to ensure the network remains stable. An independent analysis noted that 18 of 19 affected MetaMask validators directed rewards to an address linked to the Tornado Cash mixer. The amount directed to the Tornado Cash address totaled approximately 0.36 ETH, or less than $1,000 at current prices. This incident follows the September 2025 withdrawal of all Kiln validators after a potential infrastructure compromise. Mona El Isa, CEO of Avantgarde Finance, warns that if any party amassed that much control, they could potentially alter the state of the blockchain itself, which poses serious risks to security.

Join the discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *