Live
USD · 24h
Regulation

SEC crypto enforcement: myths vs facts after Hester Peirce’s push

SEC enforcement actions against Binance and Coinbase highlight the friction caused by applying the 1946 Howey Test to digital assets. Unpredictable regulatory decisions under Gensler have caused prolonged destabilization across cryptocurrency markets.

SEC crypto enforcement: myths vs facts after Hester Peirce's push

Regulatory enforcement and the Howey Test

The SEC filed 13 charges against Binance entities and founder Changpeng Zhao on June 5, 2023, as they alleged the mishandling of customer funds and the operation of the business without any proper registration or regulatory oversight. On June 6, 2023, the agency charged Coinbase as it operated an unregistered securities exchange, broker, and clearing agency. The SEC applies the Howey Test, a 1946 Supreme Court decision, to classify crypto assets. This test defines a security as "an investment of money in a common enterprise with profits to come solely from the efforts of others". Critics argue this 1946 definition fails the decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies. Economists found that unpredictable enforcement actions under Gensler, which classify many cryptocurrencies as securities without providing clear guidelines, caused prolonged destabilization in crypto markets.

Action Date Target
Binance charges June 5, 2023 Binance/Zhao
Coinbase charges June 6, 2023 Coinbase
DTCC no-action December 2025 DTCC

Market infrastructure and disclosure mandates

The SEC provided the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC) with a no-action letter in December 2025. This authorization allows the organization to hold and record tokenized equities and other real-world assets on blockchain networks for three years. You probably already know the importance of market infrastructure. This move allows DTCC to deliver tokenized services on approved blockchains. The agency also adopted a cybersecurity risk management rule on July 26, 2023, to encourage public companies to manage and disclose cybersecurity risk. Some experts argue the rule’s broad, materiality-based thresholds and reliance on company-defined terms create challenges for consistent reporting. The SEC also decided on a climate disclosure rule in 2024. This rule requires companies to disclose their risk of being impacted by climate change and their risks regarding profits from growing climate change regulations. The Consolidated Audit Trail, which the SEC first proposed in 2010, collects data regarding trading in the U.S. equities and options markets. Reporting into this system continued in phases from 2018 to 2024.

Oversight failures and historical criticism

The SEC faces criticism for being "too ‘tentative and fearful’ in confronting wrongdoing on Wall Street" and for its poor job holding executives accountable. Approximately 45% of institutional investors thought that better oversight by the SEC could have prevented the Madoff fraud. Harry Markopolos complained to the SEC in 2000, stating that Madoff’s reported profits seemed impossible through his claimed investment strategies. The agency also faced scrutiny regarding its Inspector General, H. David Kotz. An independent review in 2012 concluded that Kotz violated ethics rules because he oversaw probes involving people with whom he had personal relationships. The report specifically noted his friendship with Markopolos. An investigation in 1992 into a Madoff feeder fund saw assistant director Eric Swanson meet Madoff’s niece, Shana Madoff, while he examined whether the firm ran a Ponzi scheme. Swanson later married Shana Madoff after the investigation ended. The agency also settled a wrongful termination lawsuit in 2010 with former enforcement lawyer Gary J. Aguirre, who attempted to subpoena John J. Mack in an insider trading case that involved Pequot Capital Management.

The Project on Government Oversight criticized the agency in 2009 for failing to implement more than half of the recommendations from its Inspector General. The group noted that the SEC took no action on 27 out of 52 recommended reforms in the prior two years. The agency also saw 197 of 312 recommendations in audit reports remain in a "pending" status. Some recommended reforms included imposing disciplinary action on SEC employees who receive improper gifts or favors from financial companies. Former employee Darcy Flynn reported that the agency routinely destroyed thousands of documents related to preliminary investigations of financial companies like Deutsche Bank and Goldman Sachs. These documents included "Matters Under Inquiry" from the first stages of the investigation process. The agency routinely practiced this destruction as early as the 1990s. The investigation ended after the agency staff met to discuss the destruction. Will the agency ever provide the clarity the industry demands? The SEC’s current approach creates significant friction within the crypto market.

Join the discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *