The history of Tornado Cash sanctions and legal disputes
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned OFAC sanctions on Tornado Cash after determining that immutable smart contracts do not constitute property. While the Treasury Department removed the protocol from its SDN list in March 2025, co-founder Roman Storm still faces legal proceedings.
OFAC designation and laundering allegations
In August 2022, the Office of Foreign Assets Control sanctioned the Ethereum-based mixer Tornado Cash. The agency accused the protocol of laundering over $7 billion in digital currency since its 2019 launch. This total includes over $455 million stolen by the North Korean Lazarus Group in a major virtual currency heist. The Treasury Department also linked the service to the $96 million Harmony Bridge heist in June 2022 and the $7.8 million Nomad heist in August 2022. The designation applied to the decentralized application and approximately 40 associated Ethereum and USD Coin wallet addresses. This action followed the May 2022 designation of the mixer Blender.io. Tornado Cash allows users to deposit cryptocurrencies, mix them with others, and withdraw them to new addresses to hide transaction histories. In 2021, TRM Labs reported that the service was used in over 35 platform attacks to fund exploit wallets or hide movements of stolen crypto. North Korea has stolen over $2 billion in the last two years.
The Fifth Circuit overturns sanctions on code
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the sanctions in November 2024 because the court determined that the immutable smart contracts used by Tornado Cash do not constitute property under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. Because these self-executing lines of code lack central ownership or control, they fall outside OFAC jurisdiction. The court rejected the previous district court’s theory that smart contracts function like machines that perform transactions. You should know that this ruling allows U.S. individuals to access privacy protocols like Tornado Cash again. The decision clarifies the distinction between sanctioning a person and sanctioning autonomous software; the government’s attempt to classify code as property was a transparent overreach. The plaintiffs, a group of six Ethereum blockchain users, filed suit in the Western District of Texas. They argued the designation violated their First Amendment free speech rights and constituted a taking under the Fifth Amendment. Advocacy groups including the Blockchain Association and the DeFi Education Fund filed a brief in the United States District Court in Austin. These groups argued that Tornado Cash is software rather than a person or property. The brief introduced the major questions doctrine to argue that OFAC lacked the authority to expand its powers into uncharted digital territory.
Delisting and the status of the founders
The Treasury Department finalized the removal of Tornado Cash from its Specially Designated Nationals list on March 21, 2025. This followed the Trump administration’s decision to review policy after the appellate court decision. While the protocol is no longer sanctioned, co-founder Roman Semenov remains on the sanctions list. Roman Storm, 36, faces continued legal proceedings after his 2023 arrest. A Manhattan jury found Storm guilty of conspiracy to operate an unlicensed money transmitting business, but they deadlocked on money laundering and sanctions evasion charges. The DOJ indictment alleges the service helped hide more than $1 billion in criminal proceeds. It claims that Storm and Semenov failed to establish effective know-your-customer or anti-money laundering programs. The charges against Storm include conspiracy to commit money laundering and conspiracy to commit sanctions violations, which carry a maximum of 20 years in prison. Following the court decision, the native TORN token price surged from $8.08 to $25.28 before trading at $18.6.
| Metric | Detail |
|---|---|
| Total Laundered Allegations | $7 billion |
| Lazarus Group Theft | $455 million |
| Harmony Bridge Heist | $96 million |
| Nomad Heist | $7.8 million |
| TORN Price Peak | $25.28 |
Will the government find new ways to regulate autonomous code?
Join the discussion