Live
USD · 24h
DeFi

Parameter shifts in Compound V3 Comet markets

Compound V3 has reached over $1.6 billion in total assets despite governance setting borrow collateral factors to 0 for deprecated Comets on Linea, Ronin, Mantle, Scroll, and Unichain.

Parameter shifts in Compound V3 Comet markets

Market deprecation and parameter shifts

Governance recently set borrow collateral factors to 0 for deprecated Comets on Linea, Ronin, Mantle, Scroll, and Unichain. These changes follow the instruction to close remaining positions in the Scroll USDC Comet. Since its launch last August, Compound III has reached over $1.6 billion in total assets and $490 million in borrowing. The V3 Comet architecture functions as a single borrowing market where users supply assets like ETH, WBTC, UNI, or LINK to borrow a base asset such as USDC. Because the V3 architecture settles all debt in kind by converting any remaining collateral to the base asset during liquidation, it significantly reduces the liability for each individual market. For instance, if a user supplies ETH and LINK to borrow USDC and LINK falls in price, the protocol settles the entire position into USDC. In V3, you cannot be both a lender and a borrower in a single market. This distinction simplifies the protocol by focusing on a single base asset for each market deployment. Lenders earn interest on the base asset. The protocol includes COMP rewards in these calculations. For example, if borrowers pay 6.71% interest and earn 2.58% in COMP, the Net Borrow APR is 4.13%.

Liquidity management and risk models

The protocol previously paused Ethereum lending markets for USDC, USDS, and USDT because of a liquidity crunch involving Elixir stablecoins. Gauntlet recommended this pause to contain systemic contagion after Elixir’s instability threatened the system. Stream Finance reported a $93 million loss because it held exposure to Elixir assets. To assess market risks, the protocol utilizes GARCH models to analyze price trajectories and capture volatility clustering. These models use both Autoregressive (AR) components, which predict values based on past data, and Moving Average (MA) components, which use past errors to predict future values. The GARCH model provides more accurate forecasts of future volatility by incorporating both past information about asset returns and past variances, which helps in managing risk more effectively. The dataset used for these risk models includes blockwise data recorded every 200 blocks for WBTC, ETH, GMX, and ARB on the Arbitrum market. This instability occurs as regulatory debates continue, such as Christopher Giancarlo’s suggestion that allowing traditional banks to offer yield on stablecoins could resolve the deadlock over the Clarity Act. I find the dependency on low-liquidity stablecoins to be a dangerous vulnerability for the entire DeFi ecosystem.

Competitive parameter analysis

Compound remains more conservative than Aave regarding collateral factors and liquidity. Aave holds 8.5 times more ezETH than Compound, with Aave maintaining $685 million in ezETH compared to Compound’s $80 million. The parameter differences create a significant gap in available leverage for traders.

Asset Protocol Collateral Factor Liquidation Factor
ezETH Compound 93 95
ezETH Aave 88 91

Hold your position on Aave, and your car can go between 100 and 140mph, but on Compound, the car only goes 50 to 80mph. Compound uses a liquidation factor of 95 for ezETH, while Aave uses 91. This higher factor means Compound provides a larger premium to liquidators to clear debt quickly. Aave’s parameters for most looped assets are more risk-on, which attracts far more deposits. Compound is at a disadvantage with Aave on two points: collateral factors for looped assets and supply side liquidity. To compete for looping TVL, the Compound DAO must consider if matching Aave’s looping parameters is a viable strategy through incentive campaigns like Contango or Vaultcraft. I see that Aave’s more generous parameters and deeper supply-side liquidity draw more users. Why does the protocol continue to prioritize such extreme conservatism when competitors capture more volume?

Join the discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *